Podcast Episode 100: Jordan Montgomery Sent Down

Scott and EJ talk about the trade deadline moves, Jordan Montgomery's demotion, and what to do when Aaron Hicks returns.

We're sponsored by seatswaptickets.com, a great new website where fans can trade their unused tickets with other fans. Use the promo code "SWAP" to get $20 off your next purchase on Swap Seat's partner website, Seat Geek.

Want to help us out? Please share this podcast with at least one of your friends. We're proud of the podcasts we put out, and would like to try and reach more people. Thank you for listening!

Subscribe on iTunes

Please leave us a review!

RSS Feed

Game # 110: Yanks (58-51) vs Cleveland (59-49)

Yanks can't win the series, but a win today means they don't lose the series.

Yanks Offense Status: On life support.

Holliday to 10 Day DL. Cooper recalled. Talk about kissing your sister. For 10 days why not use Andujar's bat. (I guess Girardi's just going to use the DH for 1/2 days off. At least they didn't bring back Hicks too early.)

All I'll say is that apparently Girardi either doesn't think Sevy needs much run support or he believes it doesn't matter against Carrasco.

Yanks

Gardner, DH
C. Frazier, LF
Gregorius, SS
Judge, RF
Headley, 3B
T. Frazier, 3B
Ellsbury, CF
Torreyes, 2B
Romine, C
Serevino, P

Cleveland

  1. 2B: Jason Kipnis
  2. SS: Francisco Lindor
  3. LF: Michael Brantley
  4. 3B: Jose Ramirez
  5. DH: Edwin Encarnacion
  6. 1B: Carlos Santana
  7. CF: Bradley Zimmer
  8. RF: Abraham Almonte
  9. C: Roberto Perez
  10. SP: Carlos Carrasco

 

 

Game on YES.

Game # 109: Yanks (57-51) vs Cleveland (59-48)

 

Yankee Offense Status: Zombie (upgraded from Dead)

No C-Fraz, Holliday, or Wade. Romine squats. Sanchez with another half-day in. Ells returns -- hopefuly with a live bat.

Can Monty stop the slide? Is this his last game with the Yanks before Sept? Can Judge get back on track? Can Ells do anything (but run)? Can the Yanks win a game?

Yanks

  1. LF: Brett Gardner
  2. 1B: Chase Headley
  3. RF: Aaron Judge
  4. SS: Didi Gregorius
  5. DH: Gary Sanchez
  6. CF: Jacoby Ellsbury
  7. 3B: Todd Frazier
  8. 2B: Ronald Torreyes
  9. C: Austin Romine
  10. SP: Jordan Montgomery

Cleveland

  1. SS: Francisco Lindor
  2. RF: Brandon Guyer
  3. LF: Michael Brantley
  4. 2B: Jose Ramirez
  5. DH: Edwin Encarnacion
  6. 1B: Carlos Santana
  7. CF: Austin Jackson
  8. C: Yan Gomes
  9. 3B: Giovanny Urshela
  10. SP: Danny Salazar

Game on YES and MLBN.

Game # 108: Yankees (57-50) vs Cleve (58-48)

Yanks, losers of 3 in a row and 4 of 5, get back Judge, Holliday, and T-Fraz, aka The Grateful Dead (considering whose on the mound). Torreyes starts again vs RHP.

Can Gracia, the forgotten addition,  be the stopper? Can ANYONE get some hits with RISP?

Yankees

Gardner, CF
C. Frazier, LF
Judge, RF
Sanchez, C
Gregorius, SS
Holliday, DH
Headley, 1B
T. Frazier, 3B
Torreyes, 2B
Garcia, P

Cleve

Lindor, SS
Guyer, RF
Brantley, LF
Ramirez, 3B
Encarnacion, DH
Santana, 1B
Jackson, CF
Perez, C
Urshela, 2B
Bauer, P

Game on YES and MLBN.

Game # 107: Yanks (57-49) vs Cleveland (57-48)

On the surface it looks like Girardi has sent of his "white flag" lineup. But Judge, Holliday, and T. Frazier have all been underperforming, and in fact hurting the team.

Ells in. Wade in -- poor guy, he had a couple of hits and now has to face Kluber! Torreyes in. Romine squats. Sanchez gets half day in.

Yanks

Gardner, LF
C. Frazier, RF
Gregorius, SS
Sanchez, DH
Ellsbury, CF
Headley, 1B
Torreyes, 3B
Romine, C
Wade, 2B
Gray, P

Cleveland

Zimmer, CF
Lindor, SS
Brantley, LF
Ramirez, 3B
Encarnacion, DH
Santana. 1B
Guyer, RF
Gomes, C
Gonzalez, 2B
Kluber, P

Game on YES and MLBN

Game # 106: Detroit (48-57) vs Yankees (57-48)

Yankees need to win this game to salvage the series and the homestand. This is one of the few times I wish that YS3 had a roof --  they could close and try to covince Tanaka it was a night game.

C-Fraz sits -- Yankees at half-Frazier strength. Wade sits.

Detroit

Kinsler, 2B
Adduci, RF
Upton, LF
Cabrera, 1B
Castellanos, 3B
Martinez, DH
Mahtook, CF
McCann, C
Romine, SS
Zimmerman, P

Yankees

Gardner, LF
Ellsbury, CF
Judge, RF
Sanchez, C
Gregorius, SS
Holliday, DH
Headley, 1B
T. Frazier, 3B
Torreyes, 2B
Tanaka, P

Game on YES and MLBN.

Game # 105: Tigers (47-57) vs Yanks (57-47)

Tonight we find out if our Sanchez is better than their Sanchez. (HINT: Yes!)

After last night's game Holder and Cooper were optioned to SWB. Nothing from NYY PR Dept twitter account about additions, but they do need space for Gray and Garcia.

Ells sits again. DD's back, so is Gardy. Wade gets another start. Hicks and Romine are back in the lineup..........the Detroit ones.

Tigers

Kinsler, 2B
Mahtook, CF
Upton, LF
Cabrerra, DH
Castellanos, 3B
McCann, C
Hicks, 1B
Machado, SS
Romine, RF
Sanchez, P

Yanks

Gardner, CF
C. Frazier, LF
Judge, RF
Sanchez, C
Gregorius, SS
Holliday, DH
Headley, 1B
T. Frazier, 3B
Wade, 2B
Sabathia, P

Game on YES and MLBN

Loving The Trade!

There might be a few quick hits on the trade appearing on these pages in the coming hours and days.  

We're also working on a podcast with our exemplary staff.

Here's my perspective - I LOVE IT!

For too many years I have felt that the Yankees have been content to just see what happens, but to not go for it.  We have seen many big names get linked to the Yankees, but we've also seen the Yankees fail to land the big player - or the potential difference maker.  I'm not here to research and rehash all of those old discussions.

Further, I was thrilled last year when the Yankees used the trade chips they had to rebuild their farm system.  The results of last year's selling are paying dividends today - at least indirectly.

What I love about today's big SONNY GRAY! (excuse, me, at least for now, when I write or say that player's name, I need to jump and shout for joy) trade is that, this year, finally, the Yankees are going for it!

What I love about today's SONNY GRAY! (sorry...) trade is that the Yankees are going for it, but not, at the same time, mortgaging their immediate future.

When the 2017 season began, there was a lot of anticipation among Yankees fans that this would be a fun year watching a new core be introduced and grow together.  For me, this felt like 1994 or 1995 - the future promise was there, but it didn't feel like the time was quite right.

But, the outstanding play of so many, and the fact that after a horrendous stretch, they have rebounded and are actually in first place has made believers of me.  I have high hopes for this team in 2017, but even more in 2018 and 2019.  And, from my perspective, this trade helps meet all of those ends. 

When healthy, SONNY GRAY! (Ok, I'll stop) is a top-rate pitcher.  He's an anchor.  He could be a difference maker in 2017, but even if the Yankees fall short, he and Luis Severino combine to be a very strong 1 and 2 punch in the rotation for the next few years at least.

I am all in favor of trading prospects for high-end, young, controllable talent.  That's what Sonny Gray is.  He'll help the team today - and tomorrow.  From my perspective at least, that makes the trade a good one.

But, you ask, what did they give up?

James Kaprielian - I know scouts are very high on Kaprielian.  He has a world of talent.  But, in his short time as a professional, he has been hurt twice, went through Tommy John surgery, and is a question mark (a question mark with very high potential) going forward.  At best, Kaprielian is a pitcher for tomorrow.  The Yankees need a pitcher today - and they got one. One who can also help tomorrow.  Kaprielian has lost two precious years of development.  If he becomes the pitcher we all hope he can be, there is nothing precluding the Yankees from getting him as he becomes too expensive for the A's.  (That's the Yankees way...in a way.)

Dustin Fowler - Again, a player with great upside.  But, a player, from my perspective, without a future on the Yankees.  For 2017 and 2018, I don't see any room for Fowler in the crowded (and talented) Yankees outfield of Judge, Frazier, Gardner, Hicks, and Ellsbury.  (After 2018, I have dreams of Bryce Harper joining the team as a piece to help secure a few championships.) Where would Fowler fir in any of this schematic?  Even if the Yankees don't eventually acquire Harper, Estevan Florial should be knocking on the door.  The Yankees have an overstock in this department, it's best to deal from strength.

Jorge Mateo - Again, a prized talent - without a spot.  It seems to me that Didi Gregorius is the shortstop of today and many more tomorrows.  Gleyber Torres, once the heir apparent, seems like he'll be slotted to play second base - maybe as soon as next year.  The Yankees though will still have Starlin Castro, who might be able to move to third base, and Miguel Andujar should also be knocking at the door.  Mateo might be great someday, but his future doesn't seem to be part of this upcoming (and current) core.

In total, the Yankees acquired Sonny Gray for three players with a great deal of potential.  Each could be a future star.  But each is also blocked in their path to starting for the Yankees.  The Yankees dealt from strength to get a cost-effective strong starting pitcher who should help the team both today and for the next few years.

One more note - much of this was lost with the excitement and the focus on players...  The Oakland A's gave the Yankees international signing bonus pool money - as did the Orioles in a minor deal earlier in the day.  While the Yankees have given up some blue-chip prospects who might have had a future impact on the club, they are, at the same time, quietly acquiring necessary funds to bring in the best talent to supplement the current core as they begin to reach their early 30's.  That, or, might they be thinking Shohei Otani?  Either way, the Yankees are making very sound baseball decisions - competing now, generating excitement, and also, while giving up talent, acquiring talent that will help them in the next few years.

All of that...and they are going for it!  

I love a pennant race!

Sonny Gray (!) chasing the clouds away...

Game # 104: Tigers (47-56) vs Yanks (56-47)

Will the trade ignite the Yanks?

Gardy sits. DD sits. Wade in. The team's pinch runner gets to play CF and bat lead off.

Tigers

  1. 2B: Ian Kinsler
  2. RF: Jim Adduci
  3. LF: Justin Upton
  4. 1B: Miguel Cabrera
  5. 3B: Nick Castellanos
  6. DH: Victor Martinez
  7. CF: Mikie Mahtook
  8. C: James McCann
  9. SS: Jose Iglesias
  10. SP: Michael Fulmer

Yankees

  1. CF: Jacoby Ellsbury
  2. LF: Clint Frazier
  3. RF: Aaron Judge
  4. C: Gary Sanchez
  5. DH: Matt Holliday
  6. 1B: Chase Headley
  7. 3B: Todd Frazier
  8. SS: Ronald Torreyes
  9. 2B: Tyler Wade
  10. SP: Luis Severino

Game on YES.