Will the Yanks be held hostage by Jeter? | It's About The Money

Will the Yanks be held hostage by Jeter?

This is not a financial discussion today. This is a positional debate, brought about by this comment by Mike Vaccaro:

Now, the Yankees aren’t likely to find themselves in the quandary the Orioles created for themselves not long ago by refusing to believe that Cal Ripken would ever get too old to play — or wanting to challenge in any way their most popular player. They’re too smart to do what the Mets did with Mike Piazza, refusing to come up with a smart succession plan that not only would have helped the Mets at catcher, but also might well have extended Piazza’s career as an effective offensive player.

The Yankees aren’t likely to be held hostage the way those teams were, and honestly weren’t held hostage here. It is still the right move to choose Jeter over a future uncertainty. It just won’t be forever.

Here’s my thought: The Yanks are exactly like the Orioles and how Ripken’s eventual decline was so impossibly difficult to navigate. Sure, Cashman & Co. are a smart bunch, but if Jeter signs a four year extension and his abilities finally begin to erode (yes, it will happen at some point), will the front office be able to move Jeter from SS?

Jeter, as we all know, is one proud dude. That’s what makes him great. That’s what drives him. That’s what helped his defensive renaissance last year, hearing the whispers. That’s why we love him. Will Jeter accept moving to LF? To DH? Where does that leave ARod, who will also need some time at DH?

(click “view full post” to read more)

Jeter’s succession plan needs to be handled better than Ripken’s or Piazza’s, and done so in concert with Jeter. I just don’t think the Yanks are appreciably “smarter” and therefore better equipped to handle shoving Jeter off SS than either of those other teams with their icons.  The Yankees organization, especially during the Steinbrenner administration, takes pride in its own history and legends and Jeter is no exception.  Great lengths will be taken to make sure Jeter remains a Yankee and a happy one. 

I’m fairly sick of the Jeter-mongering because I am quite certain he’ll do the right things, because he always has.  That’s the advantage with Jeter; we know who he is and what he’s about.  I’m not worried about him re-signing with the Yanks next Fall. Nor am I worried about him holding the team hostage.  I just don’t give any front office so much credit until I see them navigate a potential storm like this one.

 

4 Responses to “Will the Yanks be held hostage by Jeter?”

  1. Brian Cashman does not negotiate with terrorists, hostage takers, or anyone mid-season

  2. Larry says:

    You can’t think about Jeter’s playing a different position until you identify where he’s going to play, and more importantly, who is going to succeed him at shortstop.  At the moment, the issue is not how to persuade Jeter to play a different position.  The issue is how long we can persuade Jeter to STAY at shortstop until we can find an acceptable successor.

  3. ” The issue is how long we can persuade Jeter to STAY at shortstop until we can find an acceptable successor.”
    What, is there going to be a run in MLB on 37-year-old shortstops?
    ;)
     
     
     
     

  4. Kevin Davis says:

    I think this is a stupid debate.    Jeter hasn’t shown any signs  that he’s not capable of playing shortstop for the Yankees for the upcomming season  or maybe the next few seasons.  Some how it will all work out so lets talk about this year instead of this useless speculation!!!!