Yankees do their thing against starting pitcher making his Major League debut, which is to say, absolutely nothing

Can someone please explain why the Yankees — currently in possession of the best wOBA in Major League Baseball (though maybe not for much longer after tonight’s fiasco), not to mention one of the top two offensive teams in the American League every year except 2008 (when they were 5th) since the 2002 season — get completely shutdown seemingly every single time they face a rookie starting pitcher making his Major League debut?

Pretty much every Yankee fan I know jokes about this all the time, but it long ago ceased being funny. While I have to imagine there have been times the Yankees have teed off on guys getting their first taste of The Show, this has been a real issue for the team for as long as I can remember. Not to take anything away from Josh Tomlin, who was absolutely and utterly spectacular in his Major League debut, but how can a team like the Yankees, with all of their advance scouts, absurdly prodigious hitters and presumably limitless technology that should in theory enable them to properly prepare for every starter they face, look so very poor against guys who have never before pitched in the Major Leagues? It is absolutely baffling.

That all being said, my hat’s off to Tomlin, who had about as fine a debut as one could hope in picking up his first career Major League win as the Indians beat the Yankees 4-1. Tomlin pitched seven impressive innings of scoreless ball while surrendering only three hits. The Yankees couldn’t do anything against his array of off-speed junk, which, come to think of it, is probably exactly why Tomlin was so successful. The Yankees’ other kryptonite is slow-pitch garbage (see Moyer, Jamie and Matsuzaka, Daisuke, among others) — combine junkballing abilities with a pitcher the Yankees have never seen before, especially when it’s a guy making his Major League debut, and I’m actually shocked that Tomlin didn’t Perfect Game the Yankees with 27 strikeouts.

CC Sabathia was good but not great, and was essentially done in by his defense in the 4th, as Francisco Cervelli — speaking of Cervelli, I hope the fans’ love affair with Frankie is finally over, now that Cervelli has shown he can’t hit, field or throw runners out and may as well be a bullpen catcher — dropped a throw from Alex Rodriguez at the plate that would’ve kept the game scoreless. The Yankees then fell victim to one of the few umpires I’ve ever seen that didn’t give the “neighborhood” call, as Robinson Cano failed to step on the bag at second while turning a double play. To add insult to injury, the runner at first was also called safe, though replays showed he was out. So instead of being out of the inning, Sabathia had to deal with the bases loaded and still only one out. That he only gave up one more run was rather impressive, and both runs scored that inning were actually unearned.

Sabathia later gave up two more runs in the sixth, which effectively put the game out of reach given that the Yankees had no interest in dispelling the can’t-hit-rookie-pitchers meme.

The Yankees actually brought the tying run to the plate in the ninth for what felt like the umpteenth loss in a row, and had three(!) chances to send the game to extras with a three-run bomb after Brett Gardner and Derek Jeter reached base with no outs, but Nick Swisher, Mark Teixeira and A-Rod couldn’t get it done. Obviously you can’t win ’em all, but it’s still disappointing when your biggest bats can’t come through with the game on the line.

So while Tomlin certainly gets all the credit in the world, it was quite frustrating to see the Yankees not only lose with their ace on the mound — this was Sabathia’s first loss since May 24 against the Mets — but also drop a game against one of the worst teams in the American League. I figured the Indians would pick up a win in one of these games, but definitely not the Sabathia start. Given that A.J. Burnett and Dustin Moseley start the next two games, at this point the Yankees should be elated if they split this series.

Image courtesy of The AP

7 thoughts on “Yankees do their thing against starting pitcher making his Major League debut, which is to say, absolutely nothing

  1. Frankie is fine. He is a back up catcher, now if our starting catcher wasn't an absolute ferry and capable of playing back to back days and wasn't a complete idiot behind the plate we wouldn't have to deal with our back up catcher playing more than he has this year. Posada also is easily the worst catcher in history of baseball in blocking the plate, if he was catching last night and not Frankie Choo would have easily scored when Gardner had a perfect throw that lead to an out. Again no Yankee thinks Frankie should be playing 120 games but since Posada has no heart and can't play with a little pain we have to have our back up in more than he should. As for the other aspect of not throwing anyone out, the Yankee pitching staff doesn't even try to hold runners on so it is no surprise that no matter who is catching they can't throw anyone out.

  2. Also to blame Frankie for losing the ball on a sweep tag at the plate where the runner kicked the ball out of his glove is just ridiculous. Even the Cleveland announcers were shocked that an E was charged. There is literally nothing he could have done except maybe keep his second hand on the ball but that would have meant he wouldn't be able to reach the runner. Posada on the other hand would have just let the runner score since he avoids contact at all costs at the plate.

  3. shhh! you'll give away my secret of betting against the Yanks when facing rookies. Its made me a rich man!

  4. These are all great comments! I'M betting the house the next time a rook is on the bump.

  5. On the question of "as long as I can remember", all I have to say is Mark Fidrych (Det) June 28, 1976 one run complete game followed by another, a shutout on 9/12. That's it for my memory … hard to forget right in the middle of pennant race … Anyone figure it goes back further?

  6. Pingback: A look at the 2011 Cleveland Indians | New York Yankees blog, Yankees blog, A blog about the New York Yankees | The Yankee Analysts

  7. Pingback: Not getting owned by starters they’ve never faced before | River Avenue Blues