More Hughes News

Per Lohud, one of the myriad tests that Phil Hughes underwent indicated the possibility of a “circulatory problem.”  Hughes will be going to see a specialist in St. Louis to get another opinion, but this is not a real encouraging development.  Joe Girardi mentioned in his post0game press conference taht Hughes might have a mild case of thoracic outlet syndrome.  Hopefully the visit to the specialist will help clear things up.

What is thoracic outlet syndrome?  Here’s what Pubmed has to say:

Thoracic outlet syndrome is a rare condition that involves pain in the neck and shoulder, numbness and tingling of the fingers, and a weak grip. The thoracic outlet is the area between the rib cage and collar bone.

Causes, incidence, and risk factors

Blood vessels and nerves coming from the spine or major blood vessels of the body pass through a narrow space near the shoulder and collarbone on their way to the arms. As they pass by or through the collarbone (clavicle) and upper ribs, they may not have enough space.

Pressure (compression) on these blood vessels or nerves can cause symptoms in the arms or hands. Problems with the nerves cause almost all cases of thoracic outlet syndrome.

Compression can be caused by an extra cervical rib (above the first rib) or an abnormal tight band connecting the spinal vertebra to the rib. Patients often have injured the area in the past or overused the shoulder.

People with long necks and droopy shoulders may be more likely to develop this condition because of extra pressure on the nerves and blood vessels.


Symptoms of thoracic outlet syndrome may include:

  • Pain, numbness, and tingling in the pinky and ring fingers, and the inner forearm
  • Pain and tingling in the neck and shoulders (carrying something heavy may make the pain worse)
  • Signs of poor circulation in the hand or forearm (a bluish color, cold hands, or a swollen arm)
  • Weakness of the muscles in the hand

Signs and tests

When you lift something, the arm may look pale due to pressure on the blood vessels.

The diagnosis is typically made after the doctor takes a careful history and performs a physical examination. Sometimes the following tests are done to confirm the diagnosis:

Tests are also done to make sure that there are no other problems, such as carpal tunnel syndrome or a damaged nerve due to problems in the cervical (neck) spine.


When thoracic outlet syndrome affects the nerves, the first treatment is always physical therapy. Physical therapy helps strengthen the shoulder muscles, improve range of motion, and promote better posture. Treatment may also include pain medication.

If there is pressure on the vein, your doctor may give you a blood thinner to dissolve the blood clot. This will help reduce swelling in your arm.

You may need surgery if physical therapy and changes in activity do not improve your symptoms. The surgeon may make a cut either under your armpit or just above your collarbone.

During surgery, the following may be done:

  • An extra rib is removed and certain muscles are cut.
  • A section of the first rib is removed to release pressure in the area.
  • Bypass surgery is done to reroute blood around the compression or remove the area that is causing the symptoms.

Your doctor may also suggest other alternatives, including angioplasty if the artery is narrowed.

Expectations (prognosis)

Having the first rib removed and the fibrous bands broken may relieve symptoms in certain patients. Surgery can be successful in 50% to 80% of patients. Conservative approaches using physical therapy are helpful for many patients.

At least 5% of patients have symptoms that return after surgery.


Complications can occur with any surgery and relate to the type of procedure and anesthesia used.

Damage to nerves or blood vessels may occur during surgery. This could lead to weakness of the arm muscles, or weakness of the muscles that help control the diaphragm when you breathe.


  1. Smythe WR, Reznik SI, Putnam Jr. JB. Lung (including pulmonary embolism and thoracic outlet syndrome). In: Townsend Jr. CM, Beauchamp RD, Evers BM, Mattox KL. Sabiston Textbook of Surgery. 18th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: Saunders Elsevier;2007:chap 59.


A pitcher like Hughes could certainly fall into the category of “repetitive injuries from sports-related activities”, so on the surface this seems like a believable diagnosis.  We’ll have to wait and see what the St. Louis specialist says, but the prognosis is not clear, especially for a person who puts so much stress on his arm and shoulder on a regular basis.  However, the fact that a number of current and former major leaguers (including Matt Harrison and Kenny Rogers)  I’m hoping for the best, but am cognizant of the possibilities.  I imagine rehab/physical therapy will be the first step if it is in fact TOS, but if that doesn’t work, surgery could be looming.  I am encouraged that there was no pain/tingling/numbness reported, which could be more serious signs.

Update: Another study including 7 pitchers (found in a Medline search) found that “full functional recovery can usually be anticipated within several months of surgical treatment, consisting of mobilization and segmental reconstruction of the diseased axillary artery or ligation/excision of branch aneurysms, as well as concomitant management of distal thromboembolism.”  To translate this into English, if TOS is discovered early, a full functional recovery from surgery is possible.  The 7 pitchers in the study were able to continue their pitching careers after their treatment.

6 thoughts on “More Hughes News

  1. Judging by all of that, the important question if Hughes has the syndrome is, “Will surgery be necessary?” If his case is mild like Girardi says, he may be able to get by with just physical therapy. I’m no doctor, but removing a rib sounds like something that will knock him out for most or all of the season.

      • I think the Yankees should proceed with the thought process that he won’t be back this year, that way if he does make it back we aren’t dependent on his comeback and what the results will be.

  2. I have the feeling that the Yankees should have done this testing earlier. IT was such as important signal–to lose that much speed for no reason at that age.

    Not that it will make a difference in when he can pitch again or whether he’ll get his speed back, but it seems like they should have taken this more seriously instead of looking for excuses.

    • You do realize that they don’t know if this is what’s wrong right? The test only showed minor readings hinting at a possible problem, they still have no idea if he has anything wrong physically, let alone this.

      Let’s hold off the the hangmens noose until we know the facts, not speculation.

  3. Just for the record, the St. Louis Dispatch (Hughes’s vascular specialist’s hometown paper) and Newark Star-Ledger both did a medical presser on the syndrome, and their findings on MLB pitchers’ post-surgery recovery times and success rate were markedly less enthusiastic than the Medline outcomes quoted above.