The Young Guys Most Likely To Contribute In 2013

Opening Day catcher? Don't rule it out. Courtesy of the AP

(The following is being syndicated from An A-Blog for A-Rod)

There’s still the possibility of a blockbuster trade, something I think almost all of us are secretly hoping for after the excitement-less Winter Meetings.  But with the Yankees holding firm on their free agent signing plans for this offseason, and with that plan assuredly continuing into the next offseason when the payroll goal will loom largest, the likelihood of the Yankees having to use their top-level Minor Leaguers as more than just emergency filler or roster expansion fodder is very high.

We all know the Yankees don’t have much high-impact, high-level talent in their system, but that’s not to say they don’t have players capable of contributing as useful bench or bullpen pieces or even winning a starting job if it comes to that.  The only “top” prospect with a shot at making the show in 2013 is Tyler Austin, and even that is a longshot, but here are some other guys who could see some significant PT at the Major League level next season.

Austin Romine– C

I know 2012 was a lost season for him, I know he didn’t hit in the AZFL, I know he hasn’t hit much at all since making it to Triple-A, and I know he needs more ABs to try to get his offensive game back together.  I also know that the Yankees are probably heading into spring camp in 2013 with a collection of hot garbage to pick through to find their starting catcher (no offense, guys).  With Russell Martin on his way to Pittsburgh, Jesus Montero out in Seattle, and the luxury tax goals looming, this is probably Romine’s best shot at breaking in as the Yankees’ catcher of the future.  Fellow TYA writer Mike Jaggers-Radolf wrote about this yesterday, and while he didn’t have an especially rosy outlook on Romine’s potential, I’m of the opinion that if Romine impresses in ST there’s no reason not to take him on the Opening Day roster.  Even if he doesn’t make the team out of camp, Romine is going to be on the cusp of getting called up all season as long as he stays healthy.

David Adams– 2B/3B

A little bit of a stretch considering Adams is still in Double-A, but with the investment the Yankees put into Adams in 2012 (trying him at third base, sending him the AZFL) it’s pretty obvious they have bigger plans for him than they do for Corban Joseph.  CoJo’s limited defensive skills and late power breakout this season make him an ideal add-on as part of a trade package, while Adams’ defensive flexibility and more well-rounded offensive game make him an attractive option as a utility infielder on the bench.  The competition won’t be too steep, and now that he’s come all the way back health-wise from his ankle injury Adams could find himself on the fast track to Triple-A and the Majors if he’s swinging a hot bat early in 2013.

Ronnier Mustelier– IF/OF

What do you do when you have a subpar defensive player with no natural position who can rake?  You find a way to shoehorn him into the lineup.  That’s basically what the Yanks have done with Mustelier in the Minors since they first signed him before the 2011 season.  He doesn’t have the skills to handle second or third base, even though he could probably fake third in a pinch, so he was used primarily in the outfield in 2012.  But on a team that was painfully rigid in their roster breakdown this past season, Mustelier could be a useful piece because of that bat.  Dude doesn’t draw a ton of walks, but he makes a lot of contact and hits for good average and power.  At 28, he’s way beyond the age limit for being considered a “prospect,” but he could be a great fit for a club trying to build their bench on a budget.

Melky Mesa– OF

If it seems like Mesa has been around the Yankee farm system forever, it’s because he has.  A lot of players have come and gone since he made his Rookie League debut in 2006, and Mesa found himself on the Yankee bench to end 2012 after going 20-20 across the top 2 MiL levels.  My conspiracy theory about Mesa taking Andruw Jones‘ roster spot didn’t pan out this year, but that bench spot is one that still needs to be filled for 2013 and Mesa’s skill set should make him a prime candidate if he has a strong spring.  He has power, speed, and plus defensive skills, all things that translate well to a 4th outfielder role, and like Mustelier he’s getting a little long in the MiL tooth (turns 26 at the end of January).

Mark Montgomery– RP

Sooner or later I’m going to have to come up with a clever nickname and possibly a Photoshop for Montgomery, and by the looks of how quickly he’s mowing through the Minors it will probably have to happen sooner.  Amongst the Yankee brass and coaching staff, it’s probably already an unspoken agreement that Montgomery’s name will be at the top of the list for bullpen reinforcement duty once the season starts.  If the rotation gets hit by injuries early, it also wouldn’t surprise me to see Montgomery get bumped up to the ‘pen to allow David Phelps to fill in for an injured starter.  Montgomery’s stuff is just too good to waste in the Minors, and if he isn’t pitching out of the Major League bullpen by the end of the summer I would be shocked.

Chase Whitley– RP

Whitley isn’t nearly as sexy a prospect as Montgomery, and definitely hasn’t gotten the coverage Montgomery has, but he’s no slouch himself.  Whitley has advanced through the entire MiL system in less than 3 full seasons, putting up consistently good but not eye-popping numbers along the way, and will still be just 23 at the start of next season.  He was every effective in over 80 Triple-A innings this past season, striking out 66 batters to 25 BB and posting a 3.25/3.70 ERA/FIP slash, and his improving slider could turn into an effective out pitch to go with his assortment of fastballs.  He won’t get any “next D-Rob” comparisons, but Whitley could definitely contribute some of those classic Yankee under-the-radar bullpen innings that help the team every year.

It wouldn’t surprise me if the Yankees went with all veterans to open the season and none of these guys made the team out of camp, just because that’s the Yankees’ MO.  But the time for them to hold their younger players back is quickly coming to an end.  They’re old, they’re playing things cheap, and they need to find some diamonds in the rough to help build for the future.  There very well may end up being other MiL names who force themselves into consideration, possibly even The Mediocre Relief Pitcher Formerly Known as Dellin Betances, but if I were a betting man these are the names I’d put my money on for getting some run in 2013.

About Brad Vietrogoski

Born in Dover, Delaware and raised in Danbury, Connecticut, Brad now resides in Wisconsin, where he regularly goes out of his way to remind Brewers fans that their team will never be as good as the Yankees. When he’s not writing for IIATMS, he likes to spend his time incorporating “Seinfeld” quotes into everyday conversation, critiquing WWE storylines, and drinking enough beer to be good at darts.

12 thoughts on “The Young Guys Most Likely To Contribute In 2013

  1. Perfectly reasonable speculation and, apart from Montgomery, completely unexciting. It is a sad commentary on how poorly the Yankees have done at developing front-line talent under the Cashman-Oppenheimer regime. Yes, a couple of good ones have been traded, such as Montero, Austin Jackson, and Ian Kennedy, but, really, this regime has been running the show since 2005 and has very little to show for it.

  2. Scout…
    I have read many of your comments and thought you had a fine grasp on the way baseball works but, the one above, I must respectfully disagree with you on.
    Every year except, two of the last 16 +/- years we have finished among the top 5 teams in baseball, right? Right, well we all know what that means…yup, we pick last or very, very close to it.
    While others can restock from the draft we don’t have that ability! Fans want to trade for this and that player or sign that FA. That is what happened for many years with “King George” running things. Our minors were the worst in the world…they have come a long way, with much more ground to make up.
    Once 2014 has gone into the record books, we will see a lot movement from the Yankees. If Oppy and Cash didn’t have the interference of the front office we wouldn’t have lost a low draft pick because of signing sorye as a FA…or the contract of A-Rod, the trading of Austin Jackson. IPK was ok for a trade…I know many keep bringing his name up as a bad trade but, the guy has only had one good year in the NL and would have been dog meat in the AL Beast.
    Oppy and Cash could have been better, I think but…they haven’t had 90% freedom as many GMs get.
    As I stated above, you are one of the more knowledgeable commenters here…thank you and Marry Christmass & Happy New Year!

    • Just to be clear, my friend, I am NOT crticizing the trading of prospects for players who help now when the team is contending. I have no problem dealing a Montero, Jackson, or Kennedy. Rather, my point is that this organization produces far too few quality assets. And you are quite right that when George was running the show, the farm system generated even less talent.

      But that sets the bar too low. When Cashman and Oppenheimer took charge, it was with a mandate to upgrade the talent pool, free of external interference. I think they have largely failed, seven years into the new regime.

      I do think you make a very valid point that the Yankees are not helped by their low draft position, a consequence of the team’s success. But there are other talent pools (or there were, until Selig again changed the rules), such as Latin America.

      I suppose the question comes down to this: when should we hold Cashman/Oppenheimer accountable for a talent pipeline that yields barely a dribble? We always hear about the flood of talent at the lower levels. It is always 2-3 years away. And then those years pass, and still we see very little.

      • when George was running the show, the farm system generated even less talent.

        except for Jeter, Posada, Williams, Rivera, Pettitte, Mattingly …

    • I’m with you, but any GM in baseball would have made the Granderson trade. That was all Cashman and he would make it again tomorrow.

  3. YanksFanInBeantown – I’ll add Nunez (not popular around here, but sought after by a number of other GMs, Pineda (straight up trade for Montero)…. and how about Robinson Cano?

    • Since when is Nunez sought after by a number of GMs? Seattle wanted him thrown in for Cliff Lee instead of an injured Adams but that doesn’t make him sought after. With the way the club currently views him if teams were hot and heavy for Nunez he’d be gone, it would certainly be worth trading him for Choo in a deal like the Dbacks took on Didi Grigerious in. Nunez is an Athletic kid with some pop but his on base and defensive skills leave a ton to be desired.

  4. But one question what about Adonis Garcia the Cuban INF/Outfielder yanks singed last year? Don’t you think he will find some playing time?

    • At his age he needs to find some playing time sooner rather than later and he showed some decent power in AA, but his on base ability left a lot to be desired (walking only 4% of the time in 28 AA games) and he hasn’t even faced AAA pitchers yet. I wouldn’t count on him ever giving you much value, that way if he does it’s an added surprise.

  5. roadrider-

    you make old yankees’ point exactly:
    jeter, pettitte, mo,pettitte and williams were primarily developed when george was banned from baseball and gene michael was running the show. there is no shortage of stories of the times george tried to trade bernie, pettitte and rivera